Why giants live far from their star

The frost line splits a system in two, with rocky worlds near the star and giants beyond.

When a system is born, water freezes only well away from the star. Beyond that frost line, solid matter is plentiful, planets grow fast and end up holding on to the gas around them until they become giants.

In the solar system the line lies at about 2.7 times the Earth’s distance from the Sun, between Mars and Jupiter. It moves out around a brighter star and in around a fainter one, to about 0.45 times that distance around a red dwarf and about 6 times around a white star half again as massive as the Sun. Orbit draws it as a dashed line across the system.

A giant can sit closer to its star, but it formed farther out before moving in. The check notes it without calling it a fault, since it has happened in many known systems.

The first planet found around a star like the Sun, 51 Pegasi b, in 1995, is precisely a giant hugging its star, which it goes round in 4.2 days. Its discoverers, Michel Mayor and Didier Queloz of the University of Geneva, received the Nobel Prize in Physics for it in 2019. Such planets are called hot Jupiters, and most are thought to have formed farther out before migrating.

Jupiter itself may have made the journey. According to a hypothesis known as the Grand Tack, it came in as far as Mars’s present distance before heading out again, pulled along by Saturn, which would explain why Mars stayed so small.

Just inside the first giant, its gravity often keeps a planet from forming, and only an asteroid belt is left.

In The Empire Strikes Back, Cloud City floats in the atmosphere of Bespin, a gas giant, and in Arthur C. Clarke’s 2010: Odyssey Two, Jupiter ignites and becomes a small star. For that it would need about eighty times its mass, and the novel leaves the work to machines from elsewhere.

Open the example in Orbit

Read next

Encyclopedia · Open Orbit